"I don't think it's prudent to spend the time, the money and put the effort into this without first securing the site that this all is contingent on," Town Manager Eric Marmer said in the late summer of 2025, as The Coastal Star reported that September.
Manalapan now has that site. It is the former bank at the southwest corner of Ocean Avenue and South Ocean Boulevard, at the edge of Plaza del Mar. Since the town secured it, the project's dependency has moved across A1A to the 1981 building at 600 S. Ocean Blvd. that the town has always meant to leave. The town now needs to settle what happens to the current Town Hall before it can settle how to pay for the new one.
How the Town Got the Corner
The parcel at 131 S. Ocean Blvd. had been a gas station, then a bank, then office space, and by the Sept. 8, 2025 commission meeting the town had hired an eminent domain attorney to look into acquiring it, according to The Coastal Star's October 2025 report. A New York-based LLC had bought it in 2019 for $1.2 million. On March 10, 2026, after the owner did not answer the town's offer, commissioners authorized an outside attorney to prepare an eminent domain case, as The Coastal Star reported in April.
In June 2026, Palm Beach County Circuit Judge Darren Shull ruled that the town could take the property, and Manalapan paid an initial $2.85 million. The Coastal Star's July 29 report noted that the final price was still under negotiation. If no agreement is reached, a jury could be asked to decide how much more the town owes. The $2.85 million is a deposit toward that final number.
Until construction starts, the corner has a tenant. Commissioners approved a lease on Sept. 8 that lets MPB Property LLC, the owner of Eau Resort & Spa, use the old bank building at $4,600 a month starting Sept. 11. It serves as a base for the renovation across A1A, with materials stored behind an 8-foot chain-link fence beside the building. The approved work replaces the resort's palm-tree balcony railings with black aluminum and adds teak-look cladding. General manager Tim Nardi told commissioners the renovation was "about to start," The Coastal Star reported. The lease runs one year and can then go month to month, so the town collects rent until its own construction begins.
A Funding Plan Built Around Leaving 600 S. Ocean
The town said goodbye to the current building early. It has about 5,300 square feet including the commission chambers, recurring drainage and air-conditioning problems, and no room for the fourth firefighter per shift that Palm Beach County Fire Rescue requires, even though Manalapan already pays the county for that position. The architects estimated a new Town Hall would need about 10,000 square feet.
By July 2026, with the deed in hand, the conversation turned to money. The Coastal Star put the new complex at an estimated $20 million. Commissioner David Knobel said many of his neighbors wanted to contribute so the town would not have to borrow, and he suggested $10 million as a fundraising goal. Here is how that plan was laid out on July 29, and where each piece stood by the commission's Oct. 27 agenda.
| Funding source | Figure as of July 29, 2026 | What it relied on | Where it stood by Oct. 27, 2026 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Resident donations | $10 million suggested goal; $1 million pledged by one resident in 2025 | A campaign Marmer and Knobel planned to run, with brochures | No total has been announced |
| Palm Beach County Fire Rescue | About $8 million | A fire station inside the new complex | Fire Rescue said in September that it prefers to stay at 600 S. Ocean |
| Sale of the current Town Hall site | $4 million to $6 million | The town moving out and selling the half-acre, likely for residential development | The site has been appraised, and commissioners were asked for direction on Oct. 27 |
| Taxes from a proposed luxury condo near the plaza | Not estimated | The project going ahead | Marmer cautioned it was not a sure thing |
Two of the four lines rely on the same thing. The fire contribution assumed firefighters would move into the new building, and the land sale assumed the old building would be empty. On Sept. 8, Marmer told commissioners that Fire Rescue does not want to be part of the new Town Hall. It wants to stay where it is and would pay to build a new facility on the current site. The town has not said publicly what this means for the $8 million figure.
The Split the Commission Turned Down in 2025
This arrangement was considered once before. In an Aug. 12, 2025 presentation, Currie Sowards Aguila Architects offered three possible locations: the bank parcel, the current site, and the town library site on Point Manalapan, which the architects themselves called less desirable. One option put a one- or two-story Town Hall on the bank site and a new police and fire station at 600 S. Ocean.
Marmer and several commissioners raised concerns at the time about separating public safety from Town Hall. Some also asked how a police and fire building at the current site might affect neighbors, especially La Coquille Villas. Fitting everything on the bank parcel had its own limits. "We tried to fit all three programs on that (bank) site, but it was going to create like a four-story building that was not going to function very well," architect Jess Sowards said, according to The Coastal Star.
The design work has continued. Currie Sowards Aguila was hired through RFQ 25-002 under an April 2025 contract. On Sept. 28, 2026 it showed commissioners three architectural styles for what town documents now call the Public Safety and Town Hall building. According to the minutes in the town's Oct. 27 packet, the commission generally agreed all three were contenders. Knobel asked that signage be front and center whichever direction is chosen, and staff was preparing a Construction Manager at Risk RFQ, with Knobel volunteering for the selection committee. So a design and a builder are moving forward even though the old site's role has changed.
Why the Appraisal Matters
Once Fire Rescue said it wanted to stay, the town hired appraiser Marc Bertrand to value 600 S. Ocean Blvd. "to assist with the decisions surrounding valuation and opportunities," as the agenda item puts it. The Oct. 27 item asked commissioners to review the appraisal and direct staff. The appraisal is not attached to the public packet. The meeting minutes, once approved, will show what the commission decided.
That valuation affects every other line in the table. If the half-acre is no longer sold for development, the $4 million to $6 million has to come from somewhere else, and donations or a future vote would carry more of the cost.
The town's operating budget gives some sense of scale. On Sept. 28, commissioners unanimously kept the town rate at $3 per $1,000 of taxable value for a fifth straight year. Taxable values rose 6.94% to about $2.59 billion, so that rate is expected to bring in about $7.49 million for the fiscal year that began Oct. 1, 2026. That is roughly $471,000 more than the year before and 6.65% above the $2.81 rollback rate. An owner whose home has a taxable value of $10 million pays $30,000 in town tax, almost $2,000 more than the previous year. The FY2027 capital budget sets aside $175,000 for design. The general fund dropped 25.8% to $9.74 million, mainly because last year's budget included the land purchase. A $20 million building is more than double that entire general fund, which is why the donation drive and the old site's sale price carry so much weight.
The Guardhouse and the Gas Line
Two smaller Point Manalapan projects now depend on decisions about the bigger one.
The guardhouse on Lands End Road dates to 1968 and is in too poor shape to renovate. Nine contractors bid by the Aug. 21 deadline, with prices from $489,000 to $897,935. The town had budgeted $300,000, already up from an original $100,000, and part of the gap came from the pile foundations the site requires. Commissioners chose to rebid. Marmer wrote to The Coastal Star that if the redesign cannot come in under $300,000, "we will end up folding into the bigger Town Hall/PD building." As of the Sept. 28 minutes, staff was working on putting the bid back out.
The Oct. 27 agenda also included a proposal to extend gas service across Point Manalapan. Florida Public Utilities estimated the infrastructure at about $2.8 million, at cost with no profit, plus a one-time connection fee of about $3,000 for each household that chooses to connect. If commissioners directed staff to proceed, the next steps would be an FPU presentation in December and a separate March 2027 referendum on whether the town should borrow the $2.8 million. Separately, in 2025 Marmer postponed a planned March vote on Town Hall spending, saying it would most likely wait until 2027. No date has been set for that vote.
The gas fee, the tax rate and any borrowing question are town figures as they appear in public documents, and they are not advice. Owners should confirm how any of them would apply to their own property with the appropriate professional.
Dates to Watch
- Approved Oct. 27 minutes, which will record the commission's direction on the 600 S. Ocean appraisal and the gas proposal.
- December 2026, when FPU would present its gas proposal if commissioners asked it to.
- The Construction Manager at Risk selection, once the RFQ is advertised.
- The guardhouse rebid, and whether it stays under the $300,000 cap.
- March 2027, the possible date for a gas borrowing question, with a Town Hall vote also expected sometime in 2027.
- The final price for 131 S. Ocean Blvd., set by agreement or, if no deal is reached, by a jury.
If you'd like to talk through what Manalapan's civic plans could mean for an address you own or are considering, Marine Rollins is glad to schedule a private waterfront consultation.